After failing to secure a full-time role in extended auditions in each of the past three seasons, Philip Broberg is finally projected as a full-time NHLer this coming season. The Swedish left-handed defenceman is expected to slot in on his off-hand beside Darnell Nurse on the second pair.
Heading into his age-23 season, and with only 81 NHL games on his resume, it’s fair to ask if the 2019 8th overall pick can still live up to his draft pedigree. Today, we’re going to look at a few comparable players to see if Broberg might be able to make the leap this year.
Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
Most top-10 draft picks who haven’t played a full NHL season by age 23 would be best described as busts. From his own draft class, he’s outplayed only Alex Turcotte (5th overall, 32 NHL games) among top-10 picks. Other defensemen picked around the same spot in past drafts include Quinn Hughes, Mikhail Sergachev, Zach Werenski, and Ivan Provorov. All of those players had multiple seasons as full-time players under their belt by age 23. Even the disappointing Adam Boqvist, who went 8th overall in 2018, has played in 209 games over five NHL seasons.
One encouraging comp is Broberg’s teammate, Evan Bouchard. Picked 10th overall in 2018, Bouchard’s first full NHL season came at age 22, four years after being drafted. After putting up 43 and 40 points at age 22 and 23, he had a huge playoff run in his second season before exploding into stardom this past season. That was his 6th season after being drafted, same as Broberg is entering, though Bouchard was 24 for most of that season.
View the original article to see embedded media.
Noah Dobson, selected two picks after Bouchard in 2018, has had a similar career arc. He’s also more comparable to Broberg physically and stylistically, both standing a lanky 6’4″ and playing a smooth-skating, puck moving style.
Another defenceman with high draft pedigree that took a while to get started is a personal favourite, Ryan Ellis. The 11th overall pick in 2009, Ellis split time between the AHL and NHL at ages 21 and 22. At age 23, he finally became a full-time member of Nashville‘s vaunted blueline. He spent much of the next decade as one of the most underrated defensemen in the league before a complicated pelvic injury ended his career at age 31.
Ryan…